Child 44
- Director: Daniel Espinosa
- Writer: Richard Price; Tom Rob Smith
- Producer: Maria Cestone; Molly Conners
CGiii Comment
When a filmmaker has everything at their fingertips...there really is no excuse...
When a screenwriter adapts a best-selling book of borrowed ideas...really, there is no excuse...
...to produce the likes of this...a rambling, heavily-accented, mostly dull aberration into...the world of a serial killer. No strike that...the serial killer is a subplot, uncomfortably and hastily resolved...pity, the director was not as expedient with the rest of the story.
This is simply...anti-Soviet propaganda...Hollywood's favourite whipping boy...and, a mangled sense of history, Hollywood's favourite toy. Stalin was a monstrous meglomaniac...but, did he really say: There is no murder in Paradise?!?
It's Hollywood....la da da la la la.
The plotholes are as gaping as the director's incompetence to make any sense of Price's sprawling narrative...at any given moment, in the gloom, it would be no surprise if the characters burst into a Les Miserables anthem...that's how artificial Child 44 feels.
Could the real Andrei Chikatilo stand-up...Seriously, watch Citizen X instead...
Trailer...
The(ir) Blurb...
Based on the first of a trilogy by Tom Rob Smith and set in the Stalin era of the Soviet Union. The plot is about an idealistic pro-Stalin security officer who decides to investigate a series of child murders in a country where supposedly this sort of crime doesn't exist. The state would not hear of the existence of a child murderer let alone a serial killer. He gets demoted and exiled but decides, with just the help of his wife, to continue pursuing the case.
This film, about the secret hunt for a sadistic serial killer in the 1950s Stalin-controlled USSR, includes a brief subplot about the treatment of gay men at that time. Train station employee Alexander stumbles upon the body of the most recent victim while meeting in the woods with his lover. The police threaten Alexander with jail time and social ruin unless he gives them a list naming “men in this town who have had sex with other men. Men who have had sex with younger men, with boys.” Shortly after providing the list (leading to a montage of arrests), Alexander dies by suicide. The police’s wrongful conflation of gay men and pedophilia was indicative of the time of Stalin’s regime, during which gay men were considered mentally ill and therefore people of interest to be questioned in the case. Overall, the scene has no real effect on the plot.
An incredulous evaluation...missing the point entirely!
Cast & Characters
Xavier Atkins as Young Leo Demidov;
Mark Lewis Jones as Tortoise;
Tom Hardy as Leo Demidov;
Joel Kinnaman as Vasili;
Fares Fares as Alexei Andreyev;
Karel Dobrey as Photographer;
Noomi Rapace as Raisa Demidov;
Agnieszka Grochowska as Nina Andreyeva;
Petr Vanek as Fyodor;
Jana Strykova as Mara;
Jason Clarke as Anatoly Tarasovich Brodsky;
Ursina Lardi as Zina Gubinova;
Michael Nardone as Semyon Okun;
Jemma O'Brien as Elena Okun;
Lottie Steer as Tamara Okun